Undervalued Utility Stocks: Best Defensive Value Plays for Rising Rates in September 2025
Welcome to the Value Sense Blog, your resource for insights on the stock market! At Value Sense, we focus on intrinsic value tools and offer stock ideas with undervalued companies. Dive into our research products and learn more about our unique approach at valuesense.io
Explore diverse stock ideas covering technology, healthcare, and commodities sectors. Our insights are crafted to help investors spot opportunities in undervalued growth stocks, enhancing potential returns. Visit us to see evaluations and in-depth market research.
The utility sector has always been a cornerstone of defensive value investing, but 2025 presents unique opportunities for savvy investors seeking undervalued utility stocks. With interest rates creating headwinds for growth stocks, cheap utility stocks have emerged as compelling defensive plays that offer both income generation and capital appreciation potential.
In this comprehensive analysis, we'll examine four promising utility companies using advanced valuation methodologies through ValueSense's intrinsic value tools, revealing which defensive value investing opportunities deserve your attention in today's challenging market environment.
Why Utility Stocks Excel as Defensive Value Investments
Utility stocks have historically served as portfolio anchors during market volatility, offering several advantages that make them ideal for defensive value investing:
Stable Cash Flow Generation: Unlike cyclical sectors, utilities generate consistent revenue streams through regulated rate structures and essential service provision. This predictability makes them particularly attractive when evaluating undervalued utility stocks 2025.
Dividend Reliability: Most utility companies maintain strong dividend policies, providing investors with steady income that often outperforms broader market yields. This characteristic becomes increasingly valuable in rising rate environments.
Regulatory Protection: Utility companies operate within regulated frameworks that provide downside protection while allowing for reasonable returns on invested capital.
ValueSense Analysis: Identifying the Most Undervalued Utility Stocks
Using ValueSense platform, we've analyzed four utility sector leaders to identify the most compelling cheap utility stocks for 2025. Our analysis incorporates multiple valuation methodologies, including intrinsic value calculations, DCF models, and relative valuation metrics.
1. PG&E Corporation (PCG): The Deep Value Opportunity
PG&E Corporation stands out as potentially the most undervalued utility stock in our analysis, showing a staggering 192.9% undervaluation according to our intrinsic value calculations. This California-based utility presents a unique recovery story with several compelling characteristics:
Financial Highlights:
- Revenue: $24.5B (highest among analyzed companies)
- Free Cash Flow: $6.93B (strong cash generation)
- Revenue Growth: Modest decline of 1.3%
- Quality Rating: 6.2/10 (reflecting past challenges but improving fundamentals)
How PG&E Corporation makes money
The company's low EV/Revenue multiple of 1.4x suggests the market hasn't fully recognized its recovery potential. With insider activity showing some selling pressure ($106.1K in 3-month sales), institutional interest remains mixed, creating opportunity for value-focused investors.
2. Dominion Energy (D): The Dividend Aristocrat Under Pressure
Despite recent challenges, Dominion Energy presents interesting value characteristics with a 22.7% undervaluation. The company's massive scale and regulated utility operations provide stability, though current financial metrics require careful analysis:
Key Metrics:
- Revenue: $15.2B
- Negative Free Cash Flow: ($3.98B) - temporary headwind
- 1-Year Return: 11.5% (outperforming many utilities)
- Insider Buying: $25.7K (management confidence signal)
How Dominion Energy, Inc. makes money
The Peter Lynch Fair Value methodology suggests Dominion could be undervalued by over 5,000%, though this extreme reading likely reflects temporary cash flow disruptions rather than fundamental business deterioration.
3. Brookfield Infrastructure Corporation (BIPC): The High-Yield Infrastructure Play
Brookfield Infrastructure represents a unique infrastructure-focused utility play with exceptional cash flow characteristics:
Standout Features:
- FCF Margin: 43.2% (industry-leading efficiency)
- Gross Margin: 62.5% (highest profitability)
- Ben Graham Revised Fair Value: $2,092.5 (significant upside potential)
- Quality Rating: 6.8/10 with improving fundamentals
How Brookfield Infrastructure Corporation makes money
The company's 171.6% undervaluation according to intrinsic value models, combined with strong operational metrics, makes it an attractive defensive value investing candidate despite higher leverage ratios.
4. Eversource Energy (ES): The Steady New England Utility
Eversource represents traditional utility investing with consistent characteristics and growing institutional interest:
Investment Highlights:
- Revenue: $13.0B
- Revenue Growth: Strong 14.4% expansion
- Fund Interest: Net increase of 52 institutional positions
- Quality Rating: 5.8/10 with stable operations
The company's 17.9% undervaluation provides reasonable upside potential while maintaining the defensive characteristics value investors seek.
Comparative Valuation Analysis Using ValueSense Tools
Our comprehensive analysis using ValueSense's multiple valuation methodologies reveals significant discrepancies between market prices and intrinsic values across all four companies:
| Valuation Method | Dominion Energy | PG&E Corp | Eversource | Brookfield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Intrinsic Value | 22.7% undervalued | 192.9% undervalued | 17.9% undervalued | 171.6% undervalued |
| Ben Graham Fair Value | $175.5K | $30.5 | $232.9 | $2,092.5 |
| Peter Lynch Fair Value | 5,754.8% undervalued | 52.2% undervalued | 87.0% undervalued | N/A |
| Current P/E Ratio | 58.5x | 13.6x | 27.8x | (4.0x) |
| FCF Yield | (7.7%) | 20.9% | (4.3%) | 32.7% |
Data sourced from ValueSense proprietary analysis tools
Key Financial Metrics Comparison
| Company | Revenue | FCF Margin | Gross Margin | ROIC | Debt/Equity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dominion Energy | $15.2B | (26.2%) | 37.0% | (567.8%) | 478% |
| PG&E Corporation | $24.5B | 28.3% | 38.0% | 9.3% | 20% |
| Eversource Energy | $13.0B | (7.9%) | 50.1% | 4.6% | N/A |
| Brookfield Infrastructure | $3.65B | 43.2% | 62.5% | 6.9% | 599.3% |
Investment Strategy for Rising Rate Environments
When interest rates rise, traditional growth stocks often struggle, but well-selected cheap utility stocks can provide several advantages:
Rate-Resistant Characteristics: Many utility companies benefit from rate base growth that can offset financing cost increases. Companies with strong regulatory relationships and growing infrastructure investments often maintain attractive returns.
Dividend Sustainability: Focus on utilities with sustainable payout ratios and strong free cash flow generation. Our analysis shows PG&E and Brookfield Infrastructure leading in cash flow metrics.
Valuation Opportunities: Rising rates often create temporary valuation pressure on utility stocks, creating entry opportunities for defensive value investing strategies.
Risks and Considerations
While these undervalued utility stocks 2025 present compelling opportunities, several risks warrant consideration:
Regulatory Changes: Utility companies face ongoing regulatory scrutiny that can impact rate structures and capital allocation decisions.
Interest Rate Sensitivity: Despite defensive characteristics, utility stocks can experience volatility during significant rate changes.
Capital Intensity: Large infrastructure investments require substantial capital commitments that can pressure cash flows during transition periods.
ESG Transitions: The shift toward renewable energy sources requires significant capital investment and operational changes.
Investment Recommendations
Based on our comprehensive ValueSense analysis, here are our top recommendations for defensive value investing in undervalued utility stocks:
Immediate Consideration: PG&E Corporation offers the most compelling valuation opportunity with strong cash flow generation and recovery potential.
Dividend Focus: Brookfield Infrastructure provides exceptional cash flow yields for income-focused investors willing to accept higher leverage.
Balanced Approach: Eversource Energy represents traditional utility investing with growing institutional support and reasonable valuation metrics.
Turnaround Play: Dominion Energy requires careful analysis but offers potential for significant returns as operational challenges resolve.
Conclusion
The utility sector in 2025 presents exceptional opportunities for investors seeking undervalued utility stocks with defensive characteristics. Using advanced valuation tools like those provided by ValueSense, we've identified several cheap utility stocks trading significantly below their intrinsic values.
PG&E Corporation emerges as the most compelling opportunity with nearly 200% undervaluation, while Brookfield Infrastructure offers exceptional cash flow yields. For defensive value investing strategies, this sector provides the stability and income generation that many portfolios require in uncertain times.
The combination of attractive valuations, stable cash flows, and dividend yields makes these undervalued utility stocks 2025 worthy of serious consideration for any diversified investment portfolio.
Explore More Investment Opportunities
For investors seeking undervalued companies with high fundamental quality, our analytics team provides curated stock lists:
📌 50 Undervalued Stocks (Best overall value plays for 2025)
📌 50 Undervalued Dividend Stocks (For income-focused investors)
📌 50 Undervalued Growth Stocks (High-growth potential with strong fundamentals)
🔍 Check out these stocks on the Value Sense platform for free!
More Articles You Might Like
📖 AltaRock Portfolio 2025: The Mark Massey's Latest Moves
📖 Undervalued Healthcare Stocks August 2025
📖 Disney vs Netflix Stock Analysis 2025
FAQ: Undervalued Utility Stocks
Q1: What makes utility stocks good defensive investments in 2025?
A: Utility stocks offer defensive characteristics through regulated revenue streams, essential service provision, and consistent dividend payments. In 2025, rising interest rates make their stable cash flows and reasonable valuations particularly attractive compared to growth stocks.
Q2: How do rising interest rates affect undervalued utility stocks?
A: While rising rates can initially pressure utility stock valuations due to their bond-like characteristics, companies with growing rate bases and strong operational efficiency can maintain attractive returns. Our analysis shows several utilities trading below intrinsic value despite rate concerns.
Q3: Which utility stock offers the best value according to ValueSense analysis?
A: PG&E Corporation shows the highest undervaluation at 192.9% below intrinsic value, making it potentially the best cheap utility stock opportunity. However, investors should consider risk tolerance and dividend requirements when making selections.
Q4: Are utility stock dividends safe in a rising rate environment?
A: Dividend safety depends on individual company fundamentals. Our analysis shows companies like Brookfield Infrastructure with 43.2% FCF margins and PG&E with 28.3% FCF margins have stronger dividend sustainability than those with negative cash flow margins.
Q5: What risks should investors consider with undervalued utility stocks in 2025?
A: Key risks include regulatory changes, interest rate sensitivity, capital intensity requirements for infrastructure upgrades, and ESG transition costs. However, these risks are often offset by regulated rate structures and essential service characteristics that provide downside protection.